I have two cats and they both love toys. I think a large part of that is because we introduced them to toys as soon as we adopted them and set aside at least 30 minutes a day to play with them. The cats definitely don't like all toys, but they have a few favorites. Currently they like the stick that has feathers and bells hanging from it, we dangle this in front of them and they jump for it or we drag it across the floor and they chase it. The other favorite toy they have now are small soft mice that have a slight rattle to them but are stuffed with honeysuckle. Our cats have never been very fond of catnip but go crazy for honeysuckle. We recently found at a pet store a honeysuckle spray that we can use to refresh their toys so we spray them once a week to keep the kitties interested.